Archive for the ‘Reviews’ Category

Addi Click Review – (the real one)

Wednesday, January 7th, 2009

Here is my real review. It can also be found in the Knitting Purls newsletter. I encourage you to check it out as it is really a fabulous publication. To subscribe, send an email to infoATknittingpurlsDOTcom.

Addi Turbos are often acclaimed to be the gold standard in knitting needles. They feature an ultra smooth nickel plating which makes knitting fast and effortless as the yarn glides across the needles with little resistance. The joining cord is flexible and forgiving without the stiffness and memory of other circular needle brands. However, the price of each needle makes it somewhat expensive to own a full set of all needle sizes in all cord sizes. Up until recently these needles were only available individually and many knitters bought them as needed for projects, slowly growing their collection.

Now knitters have a new choice: Addi Clicks, an interchangeable set of needles featuring the same super smooth finish and pliable cord as the classic Addi Turbo. The Clicks set, as distributed in the United States by Skacel, costs about $150 and comes with ten sets of needle tips, three ultra flexible cords, a cord extender, a needle gauge, and a heart pin. The box is rather large, but I suppose it’s more for display than for carrying around in your knitting bag.

Like the Addi Turbos, sizes are printed on each needle (which really renders the needle gauge unnecessary, but it’s nice that they include one anyway). The US needle sizes in the set are 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 10.75, 11, 13, and 15. Careful readers will notice the absence of a size 5 and the unusual size 10.75 rather than the more common 10.5. At this time these sizes are not available. There is some talk of individual parts being available for purchase at a later time, but for now, you will have to do without. I find this rather disappointing as I often find myself reaching for a size 5 and almost never for anything bigger than a 10. Personally, I would rather see the 5 included instead of the 15. However, for those that tend to knit with only larger needles, the absence of the 5 may not matter.

The cord sizes included in the set are 24”, 32”, and 40”. These cords are a new light blue color and are rumored to be the new standard for all Addi needles distributed by Skacel. The blue cords are similar to the red cords found on the Addi Lace needles, very flexible and soft. I’m anxious to see additional cords available for individual purchase as three really isn’t enough for my many works in progress.

Joining the cord to the needle tip is easy and convenient as no special tool is needed. Insert the cord into the needle tip and give it a small push and a twist. The cord is quite secure and will not come loose with normal knitting activities. To release the cord, give a small push and twist in the opposite direction, and remove from the needle. It takes a little getting used to, but once you do, changing needle tips becomes second nature.

For the larger sizes the transition between the cord and the needle is smooth and seamless. However, I found that on sizes 7 and below the needle tip does not taper down to meet the cord, resulting in a small but noticeable lip. The join is not perceptible when using thicker yarns, but with lace knitting my yarn gets caught on this edge frequently. I recommend sticking with the Addi Lace or traditional Addi Turbo needles for lace work.

The cord extender can be used in two ways. It can be used to join any two cords creating longer cord lengths. It can also be used to join the two ends of a single cord, keeping your stitches in place in the case that you need to remove the needle tips for use in a different project. The extender-to-cord connection works the same way as the cord-to-needle tip connection: just push and twist.

Addi Clicks are a welcome addition to the knitting world. Knitters everywhere are rejoicing over this new interchangeable set and are likely to love them as much as the traditional Turbos. My only reservations are the uneven join between cord and needle of smaller sizes, the absence of common sizes 5 and 10.5, and the small number of cords provided in the set. Should individual parts become available in the future with better joining of smaller sizes, Addi Clicks would be my preferred needle set. Until then, $150 is a bit steep for me.

Ammendment to the Addi Click "review" (which really wasn’t a review)

Friday, December 5th, 2008

See this post for the original “review”.
See this post for the real review!

There have been some comments on a Ravelry board about the inappropriateness of my “blaming” Addi for the cons of this needle set.

Please note that this was not a formal product review. Please think of it as a spur-of-the-moment-off-the-top-of-my-head-talking-just-to-talk sort of review. It was more just a reflection of my initial disappointment with this product.

I do not “blame” any one person or entity; Really it was my fault for the oversite of 4-15 does not equal 10 needles. However, I do believe that the distributors/retailers advertising this product should have been VERY clear as to the contents of the set.

There are many things that I DO like about the set – but those things were shaded by my initial reaction of disappointment.

I have not yet decided as to weather or not I will keep/return/sell my set.

Please also note that there are currently 5,568 knitting projects in Ravelry that call for a size 3.75 needle (US5).

Dear Addi Turbo (a review of sorts),

Wednesday, December 3rd, 2008

Thank you for producing a very smooth needle. I love how you have come out with a new interchangeable set. I especially love that I don’t need a tool to connect/disconnect my cable to the needle. When I opened my new box I was so in love, all those lovely Turbo’s shining back at me.

I immediately wanted to try them out. I picked the second tips from the left and connected them to the 24″ cable. So easy, so smooth. So what if you have a little bit of a lip where the cable joins the needle. It shouldn’t make a big difference. I love you anyway.

I pick out a yarn. Thinking to myself, this is a five, I should use something DK. I pick out a yarn. I go to cast on…I look down at my new shiny needles…and see…”4,0 mm/US6″…

WHAAAA? How could you do this to me Addi? I’ve waited so long for you to arrive! And now you show up – missing a size 5? You led me on with your claim of 10 needle tips from size 4-15. Now I know you were just luring me with your slyness. I was too overcome by the prospect of new shinny to realize that 10 from 4-15 means one has to be left out! That sneaky 10.75 is the culprit, (why not 10.5 anyway)? But really, why not leave him out? or start at 5 and leave out the 4?

Why Addi?

–Heather

ETA: Update found here.
ETA2: Real review found here.